Too Pretty to Live: The Catfishing Murders of East Tennessee

Name: Too Pretty to Live: The Catfishing Murders of East Tennessee
Price: 1.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4 (1063 reviews)
Author: Dennis Brooks

by Dennis Brooks

Memoir

4.0 (1,063)

4.0 stars from 1,063 reviews. Top 89% of Memoir books we track.

$1.99KU80% off peak

Last checked: Jul 14, 2026

Read free with Kindle Unlimited

Price history: $0.99 – $9.99

Full price — consider adding to your watchlist for a better deal.

Price range: $0.99 – $9.99

Buy on Amazon - $1.99

0 readers are tracking this book's price

Fans of these authors will like this...

Michelle McNamara
Ann Rule
Caitlín Rother

Fans of these books will like this...

I'll Be Gone in the Dark
The Killer Across the Table
Luckiest Girl Alive

Perfect for you if...

You're drawn to true crime stories where the perpetrator is stranger than the crime itself, especially ones involving digital manipulation and psychological warfare.
You want a narrative written by someone who was actually in the courtroom, not a journalist reconstructing events from interviews.
You're fascinated by how ordinary people can be led to commit extraordinary violence through lies and emotional manipulation.

Maybe not for you if...

You prefer true crime that focuses on the victims' stories rather than the criminal's psychology and methods.
You find detailed accounts of murder itself upsetting, even in a factual context.
You're looking for a fast-paced thriller rather than a methodical examination of evidence, investigation, and trial proceedings.

About this book

A true crime account of a murder case involving Facebook, catfishing, and online deception in East Tennessee. Jenelle Potter created a fake online identity named Chris, posing as a CIA agent to contact her parents and boyfriend. She warned them that Billy Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth were bullying her online and posed a physical threat, claiming she needed their protection. Her father and boyfriend responded by murdering Payne and Hayworth in their home, leaving the couple's infant unharmed. When the perpetrators told police their story, investigators discovered that Chris did not exist—Jenelle had orchestrated the entire scheme as revenge for a Facebook feud. Using forensic linguistics and tracing her digital footprints, police constructed a profile of Jenelle as someone who manipulated her family from behind an anonymous online persona to commit murder. Dennis Brooks, the lead prosecutor in the case, examines the crime and trial from multiple angles, exploring how online anonymity enabled this act of violence.

Get the best deal every time

We track price drops, sale patterns, and predict when this book will go on offer next.

Price History

Kindle price over time. Green zones = periods when the book was free.

$0.99 – $9.99

Currently on sale at $1.99 — 80% off peak. Price has dropped 24 times over the last 5 years. Goes on sale roughly every 79 days. Typically stays discounted for 3 days.

Sales Rank

Amazon sales rank: lower number = better selling book. #1 is the bestseller.

Currently around #112K in the Kindle store — a niche title. Sales have softened 85% recently.

Rating & Reviews

Purple line = star rating over time. Blue area = total review count growth.

Currently 4.0★ from 1,063 reviews

Review activity has been quiet recently. Rating has climbed from 3.9 to 4.0. Recent readers are rating it higher.

Sale Prediction

Actual Predicted

This book is currently discounted at $1.99. It typically returns to around $9.99.

Prices shown in USD from Amazon US. We continuously pull new data to improve tracking. If dates look old, it usually means there has been no significant change since the last data point.

Curious how prices and deals move across the whole Kindle store? See the latest findings in The Kindle Report