His First Girlfriend: A totally unputdownable psychological thriller with a heart-stopping twist

His First Girlfriend: A totally unputdownable psychological thriller with a heart-stopping twist

by Nora Valters

4.1 (350)

4.1 stars from 350 reviews

270 pages~4.5 hr readPublished by Bookouture

$3.99At peak price

Last checked: Jan 1, 2026

Hidden GemHighly rated but flying under the radar. Fewer readers have found this one yet.

Buy now — this is the lowest price we've seen.

Price range: $3.99 $3.99

Buy on Amazon - $3.99

0 readers are tracking this book's price

Fans of these authors will like this...

  • Freida McFadden
  • T.M. Logan
  • John Marrs

Fans of these books will like this...

  • None Of This Is True
  • The Woman in Cabin 10
  • The Last Mrs Parrish

Perfect for you if...

  • You enjoy psychological thrillers where paranoia and suspicion blur the line between protecting your family and sabotaging it.
  • You love unreliable narrators and stories that make you second-guess everything you thought you knew by chapter three.
  • You're drawn to domestic tensions that spiral into something genuinely sinister, with twists that actually land.

Maybe not for you if...

  • You prefer thrillers grounded in realism and find implausible plot turns frustrating rather than entertaining.
  • You want slower burns and character studies. This book moves fast and prioritises shocks over introspection.
  • You're looking for nuanced explorations of family dynamics. This is a high-octane thriller, not a family drama.

About this book

When Seth brings home his new girlfriend Lily, his mother is nervous but relieved—Lily seems perfect and quickly becomes part of the family. She fits in so well that the mother feels she has found the daughter she never had. However, as Lily becomes more integrated into their lives, family dynamics begin to shift. The mother notices her husband and son treating her differently and suspects they are avoiding her. She questions whether she is being paranoid or if Lily is deliberately turning them against her. Things escalate when the mother receives a warning that references a past she has worked hard to keep hidden. Her carefully constructed world begins to fall apart, and she is forced to confront difficult questions: Is the secret she has buried about to destroy her family? Can she trust Lily? And are her son's life and her own in genuine danger?

Get the best deal every time

We track price drops, sale patterns, and predict when this book will go on offer next.

Price History

Kindle price over time. Green zones = periods when the book was free.

We're still collecting price data for this book. Check back soon.

$3.99$3.99

Sales Rank

Amazon sales rank: lower number = better selling book. #1 is the bestseller.

Sign up to unlock
#1,296#460,099#918,902Jan '26Mar '26Apr '26Apr '26

Currently #2,789 in the Kindle store — a top-10K bestseller. Climbing the charts — 23% improvement recently.

Rating & Reviews

Purple line = star rating over time. Blue area = total review count growth.

Sign up to unlock
3.5★4.3★5.0★Mar '26Mar '26Mar '26Apr '26Apr '26RatingReviews

Currently 4.1★ from 350 reviews

Gaining approximately 204 new reviews per month. Reader interest is accelerating. Rating has dipped slightly from 4.3 to 4.1.

Sale Prediction

We need more price history before we can make predictions. Check back soon.

Actual Predicted

Prices shown in USD from Amazon US. We continuously pull new data to improve tracking. If dates look old, it usually means there has been no significant change since the last data point.

Never miss a deal on this book

Create a free account to unlock full price history charts, sale predictions, and get notified instantly when the price drops.

Nora Valters

1 book on Vagrant Press

View all books →

More Mystery Thriller books you might like

View all Mystery Thrillerbooks →
The Beijing Betrayal (A Marcus Ryker Thriller Book 6)
The Beijing Betrayal (A Marcus Ryker Thriller Book 6)

by Joel C. Rosenberg

$11.17Deal
4.7 (2,743)
$3.99$29.99
Gathering Mist: A Timber Creek K-9 Mystery
Gathering Mist: A Timber Creek K-9 Mystery

by Margaret Mizushima

$2.99Deal
4.7 (1,275)
$1.99$17.99
The Mysterious Benedict Society
The Mysterious Benedict Society

by Trenton Lee Stewart

$1.99Deal
4.6 (6,862)
$1.99$7.99

Today's Best Deals

View all deals →
Greek Island Escape: The perfect holiday read
Greek Island Escape: The perfect holiday read

by Wilson, Patricia

$3.99Deal
4.6 (3,749)
$0.99$7.49
The Hit (Will Robie Book 2)
The Hit (Will Robie Book 2)

by David Baldacci

$1.99Deal
4.5 (52,796)
$1.99$11.99
One by One
One by One

by Ruth Ware

$2.99Deal
4.2 (19,163)
$1.99$14.99
Ugly Love: A Novel
Ugly Love: A Novel

by Colleen Hoover

$2.99Deal
4.6 (169,313)
$2.99$2.99
The Class of Football: Words of Hard-Earned Wisdom from Legends of the Gridiron
The Class of Football: Words of Hard-Earned Wisdom from Legends of the Gridiron

by Schefter, Adam

$0.50DealHidden GemHighly rated but flying under the radar. Fewer readers have found this one yet.
4.0 (11)
$0.50$17.99
The Dark Tower II: The Drawing of the Three
The Dark Tower II: The Drawing of the Three

by Stephen King

$2.99Deal
4.6 (18,430)
$2.99$16.24
Buy His First Girlfriend: A totally unputdownable psychological thriller with a heart-stopping twist on Amazon - $3.99

Affiliate link. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.