The Best of the Rejection Collection: 293 Cartoons That Were Too Dumb, Too Dark, or Too Naughty for The New Yorker

The Best of the Rejection Collection: 293 Cartoons That Were Too Dumb, Too Dark, or Too Naughty for The New Yorker

by Matthew Diffee

4.2 (374)

4.2 stars from 374 reviews

792 pages~13.2 hr readPublished by Workman Publishing Company

$14.99At peak price

Last checked: May 1, 2026

Hidden GemHighly rated but flying under the radar. Fewer readers have found this one yet.
Price history: $1.99 $14.99

Full price — consider adding to your watchlist for a better deal.

Price range: $1.99 $14.99

Buy on Amazon - $14.99

0 readers are tracking this book's price

Fans of these authors will like this...

  • Gahan Wilson
  • The Onion writers

Fans of these books will like this...

  • The Complete Far Side
  • The Best of Gary Larson

Perfect for you if...

  • You love New Yorker cartoons but wish they pushed further into absurdity and genuinely uncomfortable territory.
  • You appreciate visual humour that doesn't pull punches: death, sex, bodies, and the ridiculous all fair game.
  • You collect books that make you laugh out loud in public and don't mind the strange looks.

Maybe not for you if...

  • You prefer cartoons that are clever but gentle, without graphic subject matter or shock value.
  • You're looking for a traditional New Yorker collection and want the magazine's actual editorial voice.
  • You find cartoons about death, bodily functions, and sexual situations more cringe than funny.

About this book

This collection gathers 293 cartoons rejected by The New Yorker, selected from the magazine's rejection pile. The cartoons were deemed too edgy, raunchy, or outrageous for publication by one of the world's most esteemed magazines. The book features work by New Yorker cartoonists including Roz Chast, Gahan Wilson, Sam Gross, Jack Ziegler, David Sipress, and others. It showcases a different side of their work—dark, juvenile, naughty, sick, or simply weird. The collection includes cartoons about ventriloquist dummies, operating rooms, and "bring your daughter to work day" scenarios (featuring a stripper and a death row prison guard). It also contains numerous depictions of couples in bed, coffins, and wise-cracking animals, with no editorial restraint applied. According to The New York Times, the submissions were set aside not because they lacked humor, but largely because they were too funny.

Get the best deal every time

We track price drops, sale patterns, and predict when this book will go on offer next.

Price History

Kindle price over time. Green zones = periods when the book was free.

Sign up to unlock
Free$7.50$14.99Mar '21Nov '22May '23Apr '26
$1.99$14.99

Price has dropped 14 times over the last 5 years. Goes on sale roughly every 140 days. Typically stays discounted for 20 days.

Sales Rank

Amazon sales rank: lower number = better selling book. #1 is the bestseller.

Sign up to unlock
#814#892,967#1,785,120May '18Sep '22Oct '23Apr '26

Currently around #29K in the Kindle store — a steady mid-list seller. Sales have softened 98% recently.

Rating & Reviews

Purple line = star rating over time. Blue area = total review count growth.

Sign up to unlock
3.5★4.3★5.0★May '23Oct '23Jul '24Apr '26RatingReviews

Currently 4.2★ from 374 reviews

Gaining approximately 1 new review per month. Rating has remained stable at 4.2 over the tracking period.

Sale Prediction

Sign up to unlock
Free$7.50$14.99Mar '21Nov '22May '23Apr '26PredictedMay '26

Actual Predicted

This book goes on sale roughly every 140 days. Next drop estimated in about 13 weeks. Typical discount: 87% off.

Prices shown in USD from Amazon US. We continuously pull new data to improve tracking. If dates look old, it usually means there has been no significant change since the last data point.

Never miss a deal on this book

Create a free account to unlock full price history charts, sale predictions, and get notified instantly when the price drops.

Matthew Diffee

1 book on Vagrant Press

View all books →

More Nonfiction books you might like

View all Nonfictionbooks →

Today's Best Deals

View all deals →
Banchan: 60 Korean American Recipes for Delicious, Shareable Sides
Banchan: 60 Korean American Recipes for Delicious, Shareable Sides

by Caroline Choe

$2.99DealHidden GemHighly rated but flying under the radar. Fewer readers have found this one yet.
4.8 (80)
$2.99$17.99
Luckiest Girl Alive: A Novel
Luckiest Girl Alive: A Novel

by Jessica Knoll

$1.99Deal
4.0 (37,706)
$1.99$13.99
The Tower of Nero (Trials of Apollo Book 5)
The Tower of Nero (Trials of Apollo Book 5)

by Rick Riordan

$2.99Deal
4.8 (20,907)
$0.99$19.99
One by One
One by One

by Ruth Ware

$2.99Deal
4.2 (19,163)
$1.99$14.99
The Boy from the Woods
The Boy from the Woods

by Harlan Coben

$11.99Deal
4.4 (50,886)
$1.99$14.99
Twice Blessed (The Haven Trilogy Book 1)
Twice Blessed (The Haven Trilogy Book 1)

by Ferguson, Jo Ann

$4.99DealHidden GemHighly rated but flying under the radar. Fewer readers have found this one yet.
4.5 (23)
$0.50$8.49
Buy The Best of the Rejection Collection: 293 Cartoons That Were Too Dumb, Too Dark, or Too Naughty for The New Yorker on Amazon - $14.99

Affiliate link. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.